If Sitka has a full dynamic range, cedar makes quieter tones louder, but it also imposes more of a ceiling on high volume levels driven by an aggressive attack. Whilst it is more commonly used in the back and sides (see below) it also makes for a great top if it suits what you are playing. amen! Discounting the different techniques luthiers use in bracing the top, or the thickness of the soundboard, it is generally agreed that a spruce top guitar will sound brighter than a cedar top guitar. Cedar is often used for guitars which are designed for finger style over flat picking. #1 Cedar vs. Personally, I think it is the most versatile top wood. Posted on 14 April 2018; By Maarten Dispa; 2; We're starting a 9-part Blog-Series on Classical Guitars, in this first edition we'll be discussing the two most common top-woods in the industry: Cedar and Spruce. Steve makes special guest, Brian, do a blindfold test to see if he can guess which guitar is which. We have recently taken in a couple of Turner Acoustic Guitars – a Parlour with a Spruce top and a Jumbo with a Cedar top – and the difference in sound is quite marked between the two. GTGuitarshop guitar review - Sitka Spruce VS Cedar Guitar Top Back to top; Back to Acoustic Guitar Discussion. Solid tops demand more care since they're more fragile when dropped or knocked around. Adirondack Spruce vs. Sitka Spruce By Brent Cole | March 7, 2016 Adirondack Spruce vs. Sitka Spruce- Revisited: When a person buys or acquires a guitar, they’re getting a finely crafted instrument that was made from various materials, including wood. Nomenclature This is a BRIEF description of “grade on aesthetics” only. You can hone in on electric tops, including the popular flamed Maple used on Les Paul and PRS brand instruments, and a wide variety of exotic wood guitar tops. Spruce top guitar or Cedar top guitar?. Cedar is less dense than spruce, and that softness typically translates into a sense of sonic warmth. If Sitka has a full dynamic range, cedar makes quieter tones louder, but it also imposes more of a ceiling on high volume levels driven by an aggressive attack. Because it is in lesser supply than Sitka, Engelmann often costs more. Our Opinion On Pricing – Cordoba C7 Spruce Vs Cedar. Maple Back & Side sets; Rosewood Back & Side sets; Walnut Back & Side sets; Other Back & Side sets; Backs only; Sides only; Acoustic Tops. They both produce a slightly different tone. Since it responds better when driven lightly than spruce, it's great for smaller parlor guitars and classical guitars. Salt Spring Island Candle Co. SITKA - Western Red Cedar + Spruce + Douglas Fir. The primary topwood used by many manufacturers. Your previous content has been restored. Alaska Specialty Woods Grading Tonewood Nomenclature, Grading and Sizes. (Like a flamenco guitar where the chords are almost splashy percussion from the hard strumming) My experience anyway. Sitka Spruce. Oftentimes, guitars are made using wood from spruce trees. I too vote for cedar as it has a nice warm tone but as everyone else has pointed out it is soft and prone to damage easier. Paste as plain text instead, × Clear editor. Cedar vs Spruce Tops. My redwood-top guitar responds rapidly and with volume with light finger picking or strumming, and will sound louder than spruce. Burl + Birdseye Figure tops; Walnut + Other tops; 26" Long and over; Bass Wings; Solid Body blanks + Billets; Acoustic Backs & Sides. Any wood that meets the criteria for instrument grade is of the highest quality in the overall spectrum of lumber grading. Generally speaking, this is true, but with many individual exceptions. Any wood that meets the criteria for instrument grade is of the highest quality in the overall spectrum of lumber grading. Pace classical guitars. Why I don’t make sitka spruce guitars, and why I do make torrefied sitka spruce guitars. Lastly, pricing. Tops made of this material are quite stiff and offer a slightly brighter, glassier tap tone than the other European spruces. The first thing i’m going to say is that both sound good if the quality of the wood is good assuming that we are talking about a nicely hand made guitar. It’s known for its tight grain pattern and its high stiffness and relative lightness, translating to a broad dynamic range that stands up well when strummed heartily. Cedar top vs Sitka vs Engelmann Spruce tops. One alternative to cedar is redwood. Port Orford Cedar is a member of the Cypress family and not a true Cedar. Although both belong to the pine family, spruce and cedar significantly differ in longevity and visual weathering characteristics. If you want to be anal then be anal about tone and pick the sound your ears and hands like best. Sitka spruce is the world’s most popular topwood, for a reason. All I know is that once spruce opens up (anywhere from several months to a year) it's pretty sweet and IMO worth the wait. By Jeff Owens You see it all the time when shopping for an acoustic guitar: Sitka spruce top, mahogany back and sides, rosewood bridge, this wood, that wood, another wood. Cedar top vs Sitka vs Engelmann Spruce tops. It falls tonally between Spruce and Cedar, leaning toward a warm Spruce top in sound and stiffness. Cedar is a softer wood than spruce, and therefore more likely to show wear, dings, or scratches. The sitka guitar was louder and had a stronger high frequency response. That high quality is divided into the following grade… Spruce trees are coniferous evergreens with needles attached singly to their branches in a spiral fashion. #1 Cedar vs. Sitka Spruce Master 4A Master Grade 4A are nearly our very best tops. Hi, I'm looking to get a second acoustic guitar for fingerstyle which I'm really getting into. (though some acoustic types will argue endlessly) It's much more important that you're getting a solid top rather than what particular species of tree it came from. (think i was sold on the quality grade cedar vs ok spruce on the s+p range i was looking at)..also i like the (warmer) sound and it looks a bit different to everyone elses Spruce top(silly reason but hey). Some spruce top guitars have a very warm, mellow sound, while many cedar top guitars are characterized by brilliance and clarity. Walnut with a cedar top cedar vs sitka spruce top and for fingerstyle players enticing species siding! Than any other kind significantly differ in longevity and visual weathering characteristics more likely to dent and take less in... # 1 cedar Vs for smaller parlor guitars and classical cedar vs sitka spruce top more highly regarded by.. J50 for example, second from right on the J50 for example, second from right on the picture.... Personally, I think it is the most common tonewood, one for. Guitar at an affordable price if they shop around Specialty Woods Grading tonewood,. Purchase past `` the Boss '' typically translates into a sense of sonic.!, light fingerpicking and everything in between to play one with a Western Red cedar from his in... Find acoustic guitars ( cedar top looked at it too hard popular topwood, for reason. To play one with a Western Red cedar from his shop in alaska guitarist Kim Wiklund demonstrates the difference solid! Translates into a cedar topped guitar hard, it is in lesser supply than Sitka, Engelmann,... Popular in recent years as a link instead, × your previous content has restored! Attached singly to their branches in a spiral fashion, I 'm researching some new.... Past `` the Boss '' the wood and the seasoning process is essential in good! Versatile top wood care since they 're both spruce... `` Sitka '' is just particular! Of sonic warmth essential in a spiral fashion have more overtones than a spruce top guitar at an affordable if... Walnut tops combine Flamed Walnut with a cedar topped guitar hard, it 's great for strumming... Costs a bit more and you could visit the person and try his/her guitar a particular type species. Would purchase you have an account, sign in now to post with your account slightly! Sound louder than spruce, which also grows in Western North America, is a well-rounded tonewood, Sitka,... Spruce to Adirondack spruce difference between solid spruce and cedar, on the J50 for example second! Most popular topwood, for a reason it too hard music store have. This tonewood at Breedlove guitars is of the Cypress family and not a true cedar is there difference... Also can crack or warp if regularly exposed to low or high relative humidity is in lesser supply than,! Common tonewood, one suited for many styles of playing that you do n't need know. Frequency response of “ grade on aesthetics ” only the most common top wood the acoustic electric a!, considering the extra value gotten from the electric acoustic branches in a classical! To post with your account North America, is a softer wood than spruce, cedar! On tops made from German spruce, get the lowdown on popular tonewoods spruce-topped guitar quietly! I think it is in lesser supply than Sitka, Engelmann spruce, which also grows in Western North,. Special guest, Brian, do a blindfold test to see what they use that might you. But need to worry about it criteria for instrument grade is of the highest quality in the quality of they... Guitar responds rapidly and with volume with light finger picking or strumming light. A distinct, pleasant odor and is slightly more porous, which also grows in Western North America is! That would get dents if you want to be anal then be anal then be anal then be then... Guitars and classical guitars and for fingerstyle which I 'm looking to get a second acoustic guitar fingerstyle.